
This is going to sound like I didn't like the books, but I loved them and have read them several times. But there are some things that really bug me. Edward is fascinated by Bella because he can't hear what she's thinking, so he assumes that she has an original mind. She's actually not all that interesting all she thinks about is how much she loves him, how inadequate she is for him, and she wants to be a vampire. Then there's all Bella has to change to be with Edward, but I'll let Jess comment on that because it's all her crafty little mind which I totally agree with. And no matter how gorgeous Edward is (in my world he is unbelievably attractive), if all he had to do everyday was spend time with me I'd go nuts. His music doesn't appear to take enough time away from Bella. His lack of other interests is his major character flaw that makes him more unrealistic to me than being a vampire. I was also really bugged by Bella's "oh, poor me, there's a hole in me" nonsense. It lasted way too long and made me want to hurl. If I ever met someone like that I'd probably slap them.
Jacob has hobbies, like fixing cars, hanging out with the pack. His every second doesn't revolve around Bella no matter how much he loves her. So when they do spend time together it's quality time. With Jacob she doesn't have to change anything. She can continue to see her parents, grow up, have a family. They love each other with a love that seems more lasting.
After Bella's changed into a vampire who knows if she'll be the same person. She won't smell as good. She won't blush or look the same. While she and Edward will have all the time they can dream of, what if he decides he doesn't like babysitting her to keep her from eating people all the time. Half of their relationship is him being over-protective and she won't need him to be anymore because she won't be so breakable.
Anyway, I think she's be better off with Jacob in my practical mind which usually rules my heart. Really I'd rather be kissed by Edward, I really do enjoy the intensity of their relationship. Let me know if you're on Team Edward or Team Jacob and why. I'm sincerely interested since I'll be out of town over the 4th book being released.